Is Human Life A
Comedy?
The Vanity Of Existence, Arthur Schopenhauer
|
- What do you think is the strongest element of
Schopenhauer's argument for the meaninglessness of life?
- What is the best argument you can provide against
Schopenhauer's argument?
|
 |
What Does It Mean
To Live For The Moment?
The Movie Of Our Life, Tom Wolfe
Where I Lived and What I lived, Henry Thoreau
|
- The significance of "the present
moment" is very different for Ken Kesey than it was for Arthur Schopenhauer. Discuss
the difference or discuss your own understanding of what it is to live for the
moment.
- Henry Thoreau refers to "the waste of
life" in a very different way than Arthur Schopenhauer. Discuss this difference.
|
 |
Why Should You View
Your Life From The Perspective of Death?
The Death Of Ivan Ilych, Leo Tolstoi
Walden, Henry Thoreau |
- Do you think that the Death of Ivan Illych
justifies Schopenhauer's view of the meaninglessness of life?
- Ivan Illych was probably one of those men who, as
Thoreau put it, "lived a life of quiet desperation." What advice might you have
given Illych in order to avoid that fate?
|
 |
Do Clothes Make the
Man (or the Woman)?
Fashion and Identity, Charles Taylor
Being Dandy, Mark Kingwell
Walden, Henry Thoreau
Traditional Islamic Dress, Clifford Geertz |
- Give a sympathetic or critical account of
a man who, as Taylor and Kingwell put it, gives meaning to his life by becoming a
"dandy."
- Both Thoreau and Geertz discuss a relationship
between the way a man or woman dresses and human identity. Give your own interpretation of
this relationship.
|
 |
What Is The
StoicAttitude To Life?
The Enchiridion, Epictetus
Epictetus, Friedrich Nietzsche
Vulnerability, Trudy Govier |
- Can you formulate an argument which defends
Epictetus against the charge of fatalism?
- Do you think it is possible to adapt Epictetus'
idea of "playing one's role in life" to the 21st century?
|
 |
Could You Live Your
Life With No Regrets?
Je Ne Regrette Rien, Mark Kingwell
Amor Fati, Nietzsche |
- What would be the greatest obstacle you yourself
would have to overcome in order to live with no regrets?
- How would you answer the question regarding
"the eternal hourglass of existence" posed by Nietzsche's demon?
|
 |
What Is The Meaning
of Our Dreams?
Dreams, Nietzsche
Imaginary Causes, Nietzsche |
- What do you think is the fundamental difference
between the "meaning" inherent in our dreams in contrast to waking reality?
|
 |
What Is the Secret
of Optimism?
On A Certain Blindness In Human Beings, William
James
What Makes Life Significant? William James
The Energies of Men, William James |
- How would William James respond to Schopenhauer's
argument regarding the meaninglessness of life?
- Do you agree with James that it is possible to
achieve an optimistic outlook by "methodical self-suggestion"?
|
 |
Why Do Some People
Have A Need To Believe?
The Will To Believe, William James
The Need To Believe, Nietzsche |
- James seems to think that religious faith is
justified insofar as it makes one happy and fulfilled. Do you agree?
- How do you think would Nietzsche respond to
Jame's argument?
|
 |
Why Do Bad Things
Happen To Good People?
Night, Elie Wiesel
Evil, Trudy Govier
God Is Dead, Nietzsche |
- What do you think is the best way of
understanding the relationship between God and the severe pain and suffering of good
people?
- After reading the brief selections from Wiesel
and Nietzsche, how would you explain the claim that "God is Dead"?
|
 |
Can A Masochist
Live A Meaningful Life?
Notes From The Underground, Fyodor
Dostoyevsky |
- The underground man says "to be too
conscious is an illness, a real thorough-going illness" (sect. #2). Do you agree?
- Does the underground man elaborate on boredom any
differently than Schopenhauer?
|
 |
|
|
|